P.A.'s Yellow Pages ad proclaims "Stone Hearth Baked Pizza" and "Over a Million Possibilities!"
As to the former, I do think the use of a stone hearth makes a noticeable difference compared to some pizzerias that use an oven with a metal floor. Stone, like brick, tends to draw away moisture from the dough, and there's no need to oil it. The result is a firm crust that's not soggy, with a slightly charred, non-greasy underside.
I'm not sure about the "million possibilities" claim, but they do offer quite a few toppings (I went with fresh basil), including "cup and char" pepperoni (the fat little pepperoni slices that form a "cup" when baked), prosciutto, spinach, artichoke hearts, pine nuts, roasted garlic and clams, to name a few. They also do a number of "gourmet pizzas," such as a grilled-steak pizza, seafood alfredo (doesn't sound good to me, but that's just me) and a "garbage pie" that's basically a garbage plate on a pizza (minus the baked beans, thankfully). I doubt I'll be trying that one anytime soon, but it might be a "bucket list" kind of thing.
The sauce was, well, sauce, and the cheese was applied fairly liberally but was not gloppy, and was pleasingly browned in spots.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e9b3f/e9b3f941c013e1b474519e560eca15f2afe67ef4" alt=""
The menu also includes a number of appetizers, subs, salads (does anybody actually order salad from a pizza place?) and wings. The wings were OK, but their version of Buffalo sauce was kind of odd - dark, tangy and vinegary. Not bad, necessarily, but not what I would call a Buffalo wing either.
Given my preference for NY-style pizza, Pizzeria Americana would probably be more of an occasional than a regular choice for me, but for a medium-crust pie, I thought it was actually quite good, with a distinctive taste that rates it a cut above the average for the Rochester area. I'll give it a B+.
How can u leave out Tom & Nancey's, absolutely FABULOUS!!! Our families favorite pizza in Rochester #2 choice would have to be North Chili's Pizza Shack. Soooo good we drive out of Henrietta to go get pizza from these places. Check em out.
ReplyDeleteI reviewed Tom & Nancy's on Aug. 31, 2009. I have not yet reviewed the Chili Pizza Shack, which has moved a couple of times since I started this blog, and which I only recently learned is now located in a convenience store on Buffalo Road. But I'll get to it eventually.
ReplyDeletePizzeria Americana no longer make salads, haven't since about 2007-2008. The best pizza there are Gourmet Steak, Taco pizza, Garbage pie pizza, breakfast pizza and one of the most common I see, the Chicken wing pizza.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the updated information, I appreciate it.
ReplyDelete